Showing posts with label some concerns. Show all posts
Showing posts with label some concerns. Show all posts

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Friends,

This is my first time on a blog and I am finding it intimidating. I am not sure I have found all of what others have written.

Here are some points I think we should consider.

It has been put forward the use of GT terminology for identification and advocacy. I would suggesting adding research to the group. Does research raise issues of definition that differ from those of classification? As a reviewer of manuscripts I am always wondering about the composition of the sample. Reviews of research suffer from the difficulty of making comparisons. Should a classification system be developed to facilitate comparisons? We have a consensus definition today as exemplified by practice and legislation.

A second concern is the use and meaning of the terms like potential, performance, process, advanced development, rapid learning and so forth. It has always seemed odd to me that we can identify children who never do anything that “looks gifted” and still justify calling them gifted. Our critics have noticed this situation disadvantages or disenfranchises working class children. Our group should be able to answer this question.

A third consideration should \we be concerned with delimiting context in our definitions of giftedness? Does it make sense to talk about giftedness with reference to school and non-school settings?

.A fifth concern is the meaning of global giftedness, polymath, and domain specific giftedness. If there are kinds of giftedness, are there some kinds we should not address. Or, must they all be included? Where does this fit together?