Tuesday, December 2, 2008

Larry, thanks for your comments. Very thought-provoking

so let me summarize where we are at--we have now had some discussion about coming up with terminology that addresses three kinds of needs--our need for
advocacy
identification and services
and
research

larry also raised the issue of to what extent does actual achievement versus potential for achievement weigh into our discussion. Gagne has offered the terms gifted and talented to address this issue which remains a major one for our field

So, can you all weigh in on this--what are your thoughts on the issue of achievement versus potential for achievement in terms of our task

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Friends,

This is my first time on a blog and I am finding it intimidating. I am not sure I have found all of what others have written.

Here are some points I think we should consider.

It has been put forward the use of GT terminology for identification and advocacy. I would suggesting adding research to the group. Does research raise issues of definition that differ from those of classification? As a reviewer of manuscripts I am always wondering about the composition of the sample. Reviews of research suffer from the difficulty of making comparisons. Should a classification system be developed to facilitate comparisons? We have a consensus definition today as exemplified by practice and legislation.

A second concern is the use and meaning of the terms like potential, performance, process, advanced development, rapid learning and so forth. It has always seemed odd to me that we can identify children who never do anything that “looks gifted” and still justify calling them gifted. Our critics have noticed this situation disadvantages or disenfranchises working class children. Our group should be able to answer this question.

A third consideration should \we be concerned with delimiting context in our definitions of giftedness? Does it make sense to talk about giftedness with reference to school and non-school settings?

.A fifth concern is the meaning of global giftedness, polymath, and domain specific giftedness. If there are kinds of giftedness, are there some kinds we should not address. Or, must they all be included? Where does this fit together?

Questions to Consider - from Paula

Since not everyone on the committee was at our first meeting and since this issue emerged as important, I would like to suggest that we blog a bit about what the purpose is of crafting terminology--is it to aid in our advocacy efforts (legislative) or is it to facilitate identification and service provision. Are there other purposes? Are these purposes equally important? Should we be working to come up with terminology that meets several purposes?

So, for example, terms such as under-achieving gifted and achieving gifted will make it easier for us to talk to legislators about needed funds, particularly for under-achieving gifted. But, under-achieving encompasses lots of different types of gifted learners including kids who are under-achieving because they are not identified, kids who are not getting the right kinds of services, twice exceptional kids, etc. Each of these groups may need different kinds of service provisions. We could for example, list many different kinds of gifted such as cuturally and lingustically diverse gifted, mathematically gifted, verbally gifted, highly gifted etc., and define each of these. What do you think?

The Meeting Minutes

[Hi everybody,

Just learning my way around this blog. We had posted some of this into the comments area, but Kristina suggested putting it up on the main page as a post, so I'm copying it here as well. This posting is the minutes from the meeting, and then I'll create another posting of Paula's questions. Please comment on these minutes and/or the questions, and/or create a new post with new ideas/suggestions. Once we've all had some time to think and discuss, we'll create an updated summary of the conversation and move on from there....]


I am posting a summary of our first meeting--prepared by Catherine Little and ask you to continue our discussion through this blog

Gifted Terminology Work Group – Initial Meeting
Saturday, November 1, 2008
Summary of discussion

Work Force members: Catherine Brighton, Elissa Brown, Larry Coleman, James Gallagher, Susan Johnsen, Catherine Little*, Paula Olszewski-Kubilius*, Kristina Ayers Paul, Nancy Robinson, Karen Rogers, Valija Rose, Mary Slade, Sheila Smith, Kristie Speirs-Neumeister, James Webb
*co-chairs

In attendance 11/1/08: Catherine Brighton, Larry Coleman, James Gallagher, Catherine Little, Paula Olszewski-Kubilius, Kristina Ayers Paul, Karen Rogers, Valija Rose, Sheila Smith, Kristie Speirs-Neumeister, James Webb (and Del Siegle)

Paula: What we want to accomplish today:
- define the problem
- define the outcome
- define the process

Del: - origin of the workgroup in the need to have greater clarity in talking to legislators etc – who are the gifted? how many of them are there? etc.
- workgroup members selected for potential to engage in thorough and thoughtful discussion, and without being authors of specific models

Gifted x 3: Prodigies, achievers, underachievers; 10%
Jim G. presented a conception of gifted as the umbrella term with three key groupings underneath:
- prodigies
- achievers
- underachievers

This is linked to the understanding that these different groups require different kinds of educational services. Jim G. also proposed, based on experience with special education advocacy and legislation efforts, an approximate 10% estimate on the “how many” question. Later in the discussion, the key point is raised that 10% is substantial without being so high that we are talking about general education, reforming the whole system.

Questions/discussion:
- how does twice-exceptional fit? If under the underachieving group, does it significantly increase the percentage?
- what about leaders? are they achievers, or a different category?
- what about the highly creative?
- what about specifying domains of talent? (e.g., mathematically gifted) do they fall within the identified 3 categories?
- does “underachiever” blame the child instead of recognizing it could be situational factors that lead to this?

Purpose and agenda
Questions raised about what we are trying to accomplish and its implications for these questions – is this an advocacy agenda, or an identification agenda? Are they compatible?

Discussion explored how this might link to what happens in special education, with questions regarding how different diagnoses are determined – with perhaps in mind a DSM-like organization whereby general criteria are identified but different measures and treatments are possible within

**perhaps we need to develop some background as a group on how the special education advocacy agenda has evolved – maybe those in the group with greater special ed experience can recommend some resources?

The Term “Gifted” itself
Some discussion arose about the term “gifted” itself and whether we are potentially on a path of getting rid of the term. [This point was brought up a couple of different times; key points from different parts of the conversation included here.] Points discussed included the following:

- not without precedent for an organization to change its name when the label or description of the group changes (e.g., mental deficiency)
- do you lose your identity if you lose your term?
- dealing with the elitism problem

Some other terms discussedOther terms proposed and discussed included the following:
- intellectually abled (as a counterpoint to intellectually disabled) – question raised of who the “average” kids are then
- suggestion of prodigy, performance, potential to capture initially suggested categories – some question as to possible interpretations of potential
- the three-P structure is appealing
- adding a “not otherwise specified” as in special education
- Lohman’s high potential/high accomplishment and high potential/low accomplishment- developmentally advanced – potentially problematic because of use of the term to describe girls in particular who mature early (physically)
- advanced potential

Terms and Services
Issue of looking at ways for the terminology to be intuitively connected to the kind of service; question of whether the terms we define can adequately function both at the more generalized funding-seeking level and at the programmatic level

- can we construct something that effectively balances a simple structure that speaks to legislators and potential sources of support but can be then more thoroughly defined and structured at a programmatic level?
- importance of making sure that it’s clear there are different groups who need different kinds of services – not just the domain-difference issue, but the difference between the types of experiences needed for those who have not had opportunities and those who are progressing well (and the prodigies as yet another different group)
- the “sympathy” question – being sure that we can argue the need for support for groups other than the underachieving/lack of opportunity group

Transcript from 11/19/08 EdWeek Live Chat

Here is the link for the transcript from the 11/19/08 EdWeek chat on The Evolving Definition of Giftedness.

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

I am so excited that all of you are working on this project.